Shrimp Rolls: The Smart Home Cook's Alternative to Lobster

When it comes to seafood rolls, context is everything. While lobster rolls might be the star attraction at seafood shacks, shrimp rolls make far more sense for home cooking. The reason is simple: shrimp are easier to prepare, more affordable, and just as delicious when done right.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__serious_eats.com__recipes__images__2017__09__20170830-shrimp-rolls-vicky-wasik-4-fa0ffabfc59344a8a48c180dc72575e2.jpg)

The secret to perfect shrimp rolls lies in the cooking technique. Most recipes call for adding shrimp to boiling water, but this often leads to tough, overcooked results. Instead, the pro move is to start them in cold water and gently bring the temperature up to exactly 170°F (77°C). This low-and-slow approach guarantees tender, perfectly cooked shrimp every single time.

Why Shrimp Rolls Rule:

• ✅ More budget-friendly than lobster

• ✅ Quicker and easier to prepare

• ✅ Equally delicious when properly executed

• ✅ Perfect for casual home cooking

Here's the real tea: there's an optional step that can take your shrimp texture to the next level. Marinating the shrimp with baking soda and salt before cooking gives them a snappier, plumper texture. But let's be real—in a shrimp roll, tenderness is often more desirable than snap. So this step is totally up to your personal preference.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/plump-and-tender-cocktail-shrimp-step-03-4-4048145b48a3415dacb1a60eb925f218.jpg)

The Assembly Process:

1. Cook the shrimp using the cold-start method

2. Chill immediately in an ice bath to stop cooking

3. Chop into bite-sized pieces

4. Mix with mayo, celery, and chives

5. Season with lemon juice and pepper

6. Pack into buttered, toasted buns

The beauty of shrimp rolls is their versatility. You can add aromatic vegetables to the poaching liquid for extra flavor, though the final dressing will likely overpower subtle notes. The most important thing? Don't be shy with the shrimp filling—you've already saved money by choosing shrimp over lobster, so load up those buns!

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__serious_eats.com__images__2017__09__20170830-shrimp-rolls-vicky-wasik-5-ce0dc44f9bdf4d4197847ff424366bd7.jpg)

Pro Tips for Success:

• Use an instant-read thermometer to monitor temperature

• Top-split buns work best for containing the filling

• Don't skip the ice bath—it preserves perfect texture

• Season generously with lemon juice for brightness

At the end of the day, shrimp rolls are the smart cook's choice. They deliver all the satisfaction of their lobster counterparts without the hassle or expense. So next time you're craving a seafood roll, remember: shrimp rolls aren't just the budget option—they're the brilliant option.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__serious_eats.com__images__2017__09__20170830-shrimp-rolls-vicky-wasik-2-f863f09938ea41dcb489d6b217957415.jpg)

The bottom line? Shrimp rolls are low-key genius. They prove that sometimes the smarter choice is also the more delicious one. So go ahead—make shrimp rolls your go-to seafood sandwich. Your taste buds (and wallet) will thank you.